Pages

Wednesday, April 23, 2014

Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara...

Last week I received my free birthday gift from Sephora and this year it's composed of two Make Up For Ever (MUFE) products. A Lipstick, which by the way I already own! I mean I have only one lipstick from this brand and just had to get another tiny one in the same color! Just my luck! The other product I was more excited about, a mascara!!!

Y'all know I'm a little obsessed with my lashes don't ya? Here I go rambling about them, again...

They're straight, they're stubborn and they tend to point downwards! Not a great look!

Why this obsession? My lids are starting to look more wrinkly and when my lashes are curved with a good smooth fluttery coat of mascara it's less obvious!

A while back I found the "almost" prefect one in Diorshow Iconic (reviewed, here) which remains at the top of my list of favorites but a tube barely lasts me two months before it starts to thicken to the point that the brush becomes almost useless. If its bristles weren't as tightly placed it would be possible to continue using but it's not the case. Do note that I don't pump the wand. For those who don't know, pumping brings air in the formula so the mascara thicken/dries faster and although for some it's a good thing since they start out pretty liquidy for others like Diorshow Iconic, not so much because it's rather creamy to begin with.

Recently I got a small size of Clinique High Impact that I must say, impressed me a lot, reviewed, here. The combination of the brush, the formula and the price makes it a strong contender to become an HG. At $19.00 it's a very reasonable option but then there's this one...

Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara...




Oh My Word!!!

This formula is fantastic! Goes on like a dream, dries fast, resists the heat of my lash curler and keeps the curl all day!

Beautiful fluttery curved lashes!!!

Really it's pretty much amazing!

But there's one problem... and it's a big one... the shape of the brush!

I wonder who thought of that one, probably a lady with big eyes and amazingly long lashes to begin with!


Here I wanted to give you an idea of the size of the brush.


There's no way I can use this brush the same way as I use others. I'm left applying the product with its tip because if I try to hold the wand the way I would any other mascara, I end up with black spots on my upper lids! This happens even if the opening is small and removes most of the product from the larger part of the brush. This also means that you're left with a lot of mascara on the tip of the brush so you have to scrape the extra otherwise it's a thick mess.

Here for an even better idea I photographed MUFE along side other small sized mascaras and would you believe I used to think Benefit's brush was big?


On top Clinique High Impact, middle Benefit They're Real and bottom MUFE. 


Do I recommend Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara? Yes and no.

Yes since it's a surprisingly good formula that defines my lashes almost like no others have but no because of the brush. For me it's really a pain to use. If you have short lashes or deep set eyes I don't think you'll appreciate this one.

I've read some reviews and they're pretty divided. Some say this mascara flakes which didn't happen on me, while others love the brush so you may take my opinion with a grain of salt but at $28.00 a pop I say better be sure and go get your VIB Birthday gift from Sephora to try it first.

The brush for me is a no go and I doubt I'll get accustomed to it so I'll be using this one on week ends, when I can take a little more time to do my makeup. :)


Reviews:

Makeup Alley: 3.2 lippies / 5 lippies for 32 reviews
Beauté-test: 4 / 5 stars for 20 reviews


Have you received you Sephora birthday gift yet? 



Comments (16)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Oohh I'm really curious to see how this one works out for me...still a few months to go though, can't wait!
My recent post Wake Up Wednesday Linky Party #13 and a Paypal Cash + Ad Space Giveaway!
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Natalie, I think you might fare better with it than me since you have longer lashes to begin with. :)
My recent post Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara...
Hey Helene, I have come to realize that the shape of the brush is just as important as the formula when it comes to mascaras! There are brushes I really can't work with. Whether it's my eye shape or natural lash length I have no idea. I've tried one MUFE mascara in the past, and I remember it being OK (also it was summer and I was glad it's waterproof). Talking about mascaras: I just HAD to buy the black waterproof Diorshow Iconic Overcurl today! I hope it's good! Will keep you posted :)
My recent post A Closer Look at… Givenchy Terre Exotique Healthy Glow Powder & Turquoise Obsession Phenomen’Eyes Waterproof
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Yessss Sunny, you are seing the light! :D The brush is as important as the formula especially when we want to be quick about it. I can't wait for your comments about Overcurl waterproof and how it is to remove I get the feeling I may have not other choice than to go for a wp next to get the results I want.
My recent post Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara...
wow that brush is huge! funnily enough I have that in my Sephora basket (I've been plotting an order since they announced they could ship to the UK) it does sound really good, though I am wondering now if my lashes as too puny to handle the sheer size if it.
x
1 reply · active 570 weeks ago
Oh Clare that brush is big and it definitely gets some getting used to but like I said, the comments are pretty divided so you may end up liking it. :)
My recent post Make Up For Ever Smoky Extravagant Mascara...
That's one huge brush! I don't think I could use it without making a mess. Shame, because the formula intrigues me.
My recent post QOTW: What Beauty Product Do You Have A Love/Hate Relationship With?
1 reply · active 569 weeks ago
Oh Gio you wouldn't like that brush I'm quite sure of it. It makes it hard to apply the mascara evenly.
My recent post The Sunday Post, Vol. 17...
Yeah, it is a really weird brush, very big and just oddly shaped. A shame. because the mascara itself sounds pretty fab.
My recent post Review | Estée Lauder Clear Difference BB Cream, Double Wear Brush-On-Glow BB Highlighter, Pure Color LipShine & Bronze Goddess Shimmering Body Oil Spray
1 reply · active 569 weeks ago
You know Melissa with you eye shape and lashes (long and gorgeous) you probably could do a pretty good job with this one but it would definitely take some getting used to. :)
My recent post The Sunday Post, Vol. 17...
I got mine, too, but I haven't had a chance to try it yet. Didn't it also come with a lipstick sample? But I haven't tried it yet. I have sooooo many mascaras waiting to be reviewed, lol! But your review has got my psyched! I thought it was a great gift, and last year's bday gift from Benefit with They're Real was good too.
My recent post Too Faced Lip Insurance
1 reply · active 569 weeks ago
Allison, it did come with the small lipstick but it's one I already have in regular size. Benefit They're Real remains one of my all time favorites. :)
My recent post The Sunday Post, Vol. 17...
Oh! I've read really good things about this too, but the shape of the brush looks a little too large for my eyes. If only they were smaller... sigh - Asian lashes and all >_<

My recent post Femme Boulevard: Old and New
1 reply · active 569 weeks ago
Lily, that brush is really awkward to use which is sad because the formula is good. I don't have big eyes either and wish it was smaller too. Good thing it was a gift. :)
My recent post The Sunday Post, Vol. 17...
I'm going to be honest...I think I wouldn't like it that much and the only reason is the brush...that's quite thick and might be difficult for me to work with.
My recent post Cheek Pop it with Clinique!
1 reply · active 569 weeks ago
Peggy the brush is almost a pain to use, it's just too big! Sad because the formula I really liked.
My recent post The Sunday Post, Vol. 17...

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...